BILL ANALYSIS
SB 2
Page 1
Date of Hearing: August 15, 2002
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ARTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SPORTS, TOURISM, AND
INTERNET MEDIA
Rebecca Cohn, Chair
SB 2 (Murray) - As Amended: August 15, 2002
SENATE VOTE : Not relevant
SUBJECT : Recording artists: personal service contracts
SUMMARY : Institutes a damages framework payable by a recording
artist (artist) to a recording label (label) for the breach of a
personal service contract at its automatic seven-year
expiration. Specifically, this bill :
1)Terminates personal service contracts between a label and an
artist at seven years from the date of commencement of
service.
2)Establishes a framework for recovery of damages by a label,
against an artist in an action for breach of contract, after
the automatic expiration of a personal service contract at
seven years, as follows:
a) Limits damages to two albums if three or fewer albums
have been delivered, and two or more are required under the
contract, unless an artist chooses to deliver two albums.
b) Limits damages to one album if four to six albums have
been delivered, and two or more are required under the
contract, unless an artist chooses to deliver one album.
c) Allows a label to deduct monies advanced for any album
required under a contract, from the revenues generated from
the albums delivered by an artist pursuant to (a) or (b).
d) Allows a label to recover advances paid to an artist for
albums required under the contract, but not delivered, and
which are no longer required to be delivered.
e) Prohibits any damages if the artist has produced seven
or more albums due under the contract.
3)Restricts damages in a breach of contract action brought by a
SB 2
Page 2
label, against an artist, before the expiration of a personal
service contract, to a specified number of albums if the
litigation extends beyond the time the contract would
automatically expire.
4)Reinforces the holding of De Haviland v. Warner Bros ., 67
Cal.App.2d 225, (1944) that the policy of the state is to cap
employment contracts at seven years.
5)Declares that the state's policy that the seven-year cap on
personal service contracts may not be waived by an employee
and that the policy applies to each and every California
resident.
6)States legislative intent to restore the rights, obligations
and remedies of Labor Code section 2855 as it stood prior to
1987 amendments and finds that the enactment of this measure
does not affect the meaning of Labor Code section 2855 prior
to the adoption of this act, or any industry other than the
recording industry.
7)Specifies that certain provisions of the act are not intended
to affect pending civil actions at the time the measure takes
effect.
EXISTING LAW :
1)Prohibits an employer from enforcing a contract with an
employee for personal service beyond seven years.
2)Allows an artist to terminate a personal service contract with
a label after seven years with written notice to the label.
3)Allows a label to recover damages for undelivered albums by an
artist after seven years if an action is commenced within 45
days of the written notice from an artist of the termination
of the contract.
4)Authorizes an injunction to prevent a breach of contract for
unique personal services if specified minimum annual
compensation has been paid
FISCAL EFFECT : None
COMMENTS :
SB 2
Page 3
1)Purpose of bill . According to the author this measure "seeks
to remove the unfair exception for recording artists which
holds them to excessively long contracts well past the 7 year
protection given to all other Californian's under personal
service contracts. This will put recording artists on the
same level playing field and give them the opportunity to
freely seek their value in the marketplace."
The sponsor of this measure, the Recording Artists Coalition
(RAC) believes that this exception "ties recording artists to
contracts that frequently exceed the seven-year limitation,
and are often binding for the length of an artist's career."
Additionally that artists have been singled out by the
Legislature and treated differently than all other California
employees by making "the number of albums delivered to a
record label the primary factor in deciding the conclusion of
a personal service contract."
2)History of Seven-Year Rule . In 1937 the Legislature fixed
seven years as the maximum time for which an employee could be
bound to an employer but also allowed the contract to continue
beyond seven years at the voluntary option of the employee.
Since that time, three actions have occurred with regard to
the seven-year limit.
a) De Haviland v. Warner Bros. Pictures , 67 Cal.App.2d 225
(1944). In 1944 the statute was reviewed and upheld in a
case challenging the contracting practices of the film
industry. The court concluded that the statute restricted
all employment contracts to seven calendar years, not seven
years of cumulative actual service and that the statute was
a valid exercise of legislative power to promote the
welfare of employees.
b) De La Hoya v. Top Rank . In 2001 a federal district
court considered the practice of extending personal service
contracts beyond seven years through a series of options or
renegotiations (termed "tacking"). At issue were Labor
Code section 2855(a) (which applies to all California
employees) and several boxing contracts that stretched
beyond the seven-year cap. The trial court, in a
non-binding opinion, ruled that the renegotiations were not
separate contracts but constituted a "continued,
uninterrupted contractual relationship" and that "an
SB 2
Page 4
employee may not be compelled to serve one employer for
more than seven years where a subsequent personal service
agreement is reached while an original agreement remains in
effect and the combined term of both contracts exceeds
seven years." The case was appealed but later dropped when
the parties settled their differences and renegotiated the
contract.
c) 1987 Amendments . In 1987 the Recording Industry
Association of America (RIAA) sponsored legislation which
added subdivision (b) to Labor Code section 2855 which is
at issue in this measure. The RIAA and RAC do not agree as
to the meaning of this section. It provides that a label
may sue to recover damages for breach of contract if an
artist "fails to deliver all of the required service." The
legislative history indicates that the intent of section
2855(b):
authorizes an employee in the phonorecord industry to
invoke the seven-year contract
limitation only after giving written notice to the
employer stating the date that the
services would no longer be provided?[and give] any
party to a personal service
contract in the phonorecords industry the right to
recover damages for a breach of
contract occurring or commenced either before or after
its term. (Senate Floor
Analysis, Unfinished Business, SB 1049, August 18, 1987)
The RIAA believes that section 2855(b) merely restates the
common law right to damages if an artist chooses to walk
away from a contract after seven years. They opine that
"all the required service" means all the option albums
still owing under the contract when the artist leaves, even
those for which the label has not yet exercised an option.
The RAC does not agree with this interpretation but
indicates that their artists cannot afford to put their
careers on hold to sue under section 2855(b) even though
they might prevail.
3)Custom and Practice of the Recording Industry . The music
business is complex with a constant intermix of business,
management, artistic, and legal considerations. Although a
plethora of labels exist, five companies control more than 80%
SB 2
Page 5
of the distribution of recorded music in the United States
which most labels utilize. The industry is high-risk marked
by a failure rate for new artists of 90%. Consequently,
labels rely heavily on the success of a few artists to
compensate for the loss suffered on the other 90%. The
traditional and typical cycle of the development of an album
starts when an artist signs a recording contract with a label.
The label advances sums to the artist, arranges for the
recording and production of the album which are then shipped
to a distributor that acts as a wholesaler for retail
distribution. The label then supplies advertising, promotion,
and marketing services to the artist to encourage album sales.
4)Standard Recording Artist Contract . The standard contract for
a new artist signing with one of the five major labels is
based on delivery of a specified number of albums (one album
with six options) not for a term of service. All copyrights
(the recording masters) are retained by the label which will
advance the artist as much as $300,000 to $500,000 and cover
all recording, marketing and promotional costs a portion of
which are recoupable from the artist's royalties. A major
label may spend anywhere from $1.5 to $3 million to "break"
(make popular) a new artist. If an album is successful
(generally considered to be the sale of 500,000 albums-gold
status) the artist can expect the label to exercise its option
for an additional album. At this point the successful artist
is generally in a position to renegotiate more favorable
contract terms (additional advances and higher royalty
payments). In exchange the label will ask for additional
album options and to agree that a new contract has been
created which will begin the seven-year clock anew (tacking).
If the artist is not successful with the first album, the
label is not likely to exercise an option for subsequent
albums; the artist is let go and the contract ends.
The RAC argues that the practice of tying an artist to contracts
for the number of albums delivered, with no consideration of
the seven-year statute, is unfair and anti-competitive. They
note that the timeline for production, release and promotion
of just one album can be as long as three years. If the label
exercises all options an artist can be tied to a binding
contract with one label for the length of an artist's career.
5)Comments . This measure repeals section 2855(b), terminates
all recording contracts at the lapse of seven years, and
SB 2
Page 6
establishes a framework of limited damages recoverable by a
label against an artist.
Since March, the RAC and RIAA have engaged in extensive
negotiations concerning section 2855(b). The parties came to
agreement on nearly every term but discussions stalled with
disagreement on whether the measure should be (1) prospective
only - affecting contracts entered into on or after January 1,
2003; (2) retroactive - affecting the calculation of damages
under all contracts currently in existence; or (3) whether the
bill should remain silent on the issue. The provisions of
this measure represent elements of the near agreement but are
not inclusive. The RIAA argues that it "reflects a one-sided
solution based on cherry-picking provisions favorable to
artists from a complex set of compromises."
The proposed framework presents the following issues. Neither
the author nor sponsor offers a policy justification for this
framework instead focusing their arguments on the need for
repeal of section 2855(b). The RAC argues that "by changing
subsection (B), there will be less acrimony between artist and
record companies and ultimately, the fans and the public will
benefit most."
a) Damages for Undelivered Albums . Standard contracts
between artists and labels are for one album with several
options. The damage framework proposed by this measure in
section 2855(b)(1-2) may only be triggered if albums are
specifically required by a contract. Current law
acknowledges the existence of options by including the
phrase "or contractually could be" required to deliver an
album; damages under this measure are triggered only if the
contract "requires" the artist to produce additional
albums. This revision appears to eliminate any possibility
of damage recovery by a label for album options under the
contract.
b) Seven Albums; No Damages . Section 2855(b)(3) eliminates
any possibility of damage recovery if seven albums have
been delivered under the contract. In certain genres such
as jazz and country music it is not uncommon for an artist
to deliver more than seven albums in seven years. This
provision may have the effect of restricting the terms of
any recording contract to seven albums, a provision that is
usually bargained for in the private sector between the
SB 2
Page 7
contracting parties.
c) Election of Damages or Albums by Artist . If albums are
undelivered and due to the label at the end of seven years,
this measure allows the artist to choose to produce fewer
albums than those required by the contract. This election
by the artist prohibits a label from seeking a judicial
remedy for a breach of contract.
d) Pending Litigation . If a label brings any cause of
action against an artist during the course of a viable
contract (prior to its seven-year expiration) and that
litigation extends beyond the life of the contract under
this measure (seven years), all potential damages in the
prior action would be limited to the damages framework set
forth in section 2855(b)(1-3) regardless of whether the
causes of action are related. An example of this precedent
setting result is provided by RIAA which notes that, "for
instance, a recording company could obtain no damages for
copyright violations from an artist who had delivered at
least seven albums."
e) Retroactivity . The fatal point of contention between
the artists and labels during their negotiations of this
measure was its application to existing contracts. The RAC
argued that the ability of an artist to engage in the free
market should not be delayed for years; the RIAA felt
strongly that any application of this measure to existing
contracts would be impairment of a contractual obligation
and unconstitutional. This measure is silent on this issue
but the RIAA argues that the measure "creates a negative
implication that it should be applied to existing contracts
and even prior breaches. This inference is created by
Section 4, which specifies that [this measure] will not
apply to a lawsuit filed before the bill's effective date."
f) Intent Language - Section 1 . This section sets forth
much of the policy expressed by the court of appeals in the
De Haviland case and specifically applies it to all
employees in California. Of concern to the RIAA is the
that statement that "no employee shall be contractually
bound to an employer beyond seven years." They infer from
this phrase that any "contractual relationship" that
extended beyond seven years would be prohibited - an issue
not considered by the De Haviland case. This effect would
SB 2
Page 8
eliminate the common industry practice of "tacking" in
which a label and an artist may enter into a series of
contracts, none of which is individually more than seven
years duration but combined extend beyond seven years.
Additionally, the measure will affect employees outside of
the entertainment industry and extends beyond the scope of
the jurisdiction of this committee. Consequently, the
committee may wish to consider striking this language or,
in the alternative, re-referring this measure to the
Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment for its
consideration of the impact of this section on other
employment sectors.
g) Intent Language - Section 2 . This provision expresses
the intent of the legislature to "restore the rights,
obligations, and remedies" of the law prior to 1987.
However, this is inconsistent with the express terms of the
framework for damages provided for in section 2855(b). For
50 years, until the 1987 amendments, section 2855 was
applied generally to all employees and had no separate
provisions or effect as to artists.
6)Double-referral . This measure has also been referred to the
Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION :
Support
Recording Artists Coalition (sponsor)
American Federation of Musicians of the United States and Canada
American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
California Labor Federation
Opposition
Recording Industry Association of America
Analysis Prepared by : Kellie Smith / A.,E.,S.,T. & I.M. /
(916) 319-3450